Kahlua is not that hard to make - we bottle a bunch up every Mother's Day. But I have a recipe for it... I was thinking candy cane liquer might be more christmassy - no recipe though. You'd think I could just dissolve the candy canes down though and mix with vodka or something like that and it should work.

The eye pillows are a good idea... I'm not sure if they'll still think it's too girly though. I shall ask a few guys their opinions.